Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) are a form of employee benefit plan offered by companies to their employees, allowing them to acquire company shares at a predetermined price, often lower than the market price. ESOPs are designed to align the interests of employees and shareholders, incentivize employee performance, and promote long-term association with the company. While ESOPs can lead to significant financial gains for employees, they are also subject to specific tax provisions in India. This guide covers what ESOPs are, how they work, and the tax implications at different stages of ESOP exercise and sale.

1. What are ESOPs?

ESOPs are a method for companies to reward, retain, and motivate employees by providing them with the opportunity to own a stake in the company. Here’s how they generally work:

• Grant: The company grants an option to the employee to buy shares at a future date at a fixed price, called the exercise price or grant price.
• Vesting Period: ESOPs typically come with a vesting period, the time that employees need to work in the company before they can exercise their options.
• Exercise: After the vesting period, employees can choose to exercise their ESOPs, paying the exercise price to acquire company shares.
• Sale: Employees may sell the shares they acquire at a later date, often after the company goes public or after a specified lock-in period.

2. Stages of Taxation on ESOPs

ESOPs are taxed at two different stages:

1. At the time of Exercise: When employees exercise their ESOPs to purchase shares.
2. At the time of Sale: When employees sell the shares acquired through ESOPs.

Each stage has different tax implications under the Income Tax Act.

3. Taxation of ESOPs at the Time of Exercise

When an employee exercises their ESOPs, the difference between the fair market value (FMV) of the shares on the exercise date and the exercise price paid by the employee is treated as perquisite income. This amount is taxable as Salary Income under Section 17(2)(vi) of the Income Tax Act.

Example Calculation of Perquisite Value:

• Exercise Price (Grant Price): ₹100 per share
• Fair Market Value (FMV) on Exercise Date: ₹300 per share
• Number of Shares Exercised: 1,000

Perquisite Value = (FMV – Exercise Price) × Number of Shares
= (₹300 – ₹100) × 1,000 = ₹200,000

This perquisite value of ₹2,00,000 will be added to the employee’s taxable salary income in the year of exercise and taxed according to the applicable income tax slab rate.

TDS Deduction:

The employer is required to withhold Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) on the perquisite value and include it in the employee’s Form 16.

4. Taxation of ESOPs at the Time of Sale

When the employee sells the shares acquired through ESOPs, capital gains tax applies. The type of capital gain (short-term or long-term) and the tax rate depend on the holding period of the shares.

Determining the Cost of Acquisition and Holding Period:

• Cost of Acquisition: The cost of acquisition is the FMV of shares on the date of exercise, not the exercise price paid by the employee.
• Holding Period:
  • Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG): If the shares are sold within 12 months of the exercise date, they are considered short-term and attract STCG tax.
  • Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG): If the shares are held for more than 12 months, they qualify as long-term capital gains.

Capital Gains Tax Rates:

• Listed Shares: If the company is listed, LTCG exceeding ₹1 lakh is taxed at 10% (without indexation), while STCG is taxed at 15%.
• Unlisted Shares: If the company is unlisted, LTCG (holding period over 24 months) is taxed at 20% with indexation, and STCG is taxed at the applicable income tax slab rate.

Example of Capital Gains Calculation:

• FMV on Exercise Date: ₹300 per share
• Sale Price: ₹500 per share
• Number of Shares Sold: 1,000

If the shares are sold more than 12 months after the exercise date, they qualify for long-term capital gains:

LTCG = (Sale Price – FMV on Exercise Date) × Number of Shares
= (₹500 – ₹300) × 1,000 = ₹2,00,000

If this sale is for listed shares, LTCG of ₹2,00,000 will be taxed at 10%, with ₹1 lakh exempt if the total gain in the year is below ₹1 lakh.

5. Tax Treatment of ESOPs for Startups and Eligible Companies

For employees of startups recognized by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), the government has introduced certain tax deferrals and exemptions:

Tax Deferral on Perquisite Tax for Startups:

Employees of DPIIT-recognized startups can defer the payment of tax on perquisites (tax at exercise) for up to 5 years, or until:

1. They sell the shares.
2. They leave the company.
3. The company ceases to be a DPIIT-recognized startup.

The deferral helps reduce the immediate tax burden, as employees do not need to pay tax on perquisites until one of these events occurs.

6. ESOP Taxation for Non-Residents (NRI Employees)

For non-resident employees, ESOPs are subject to TDS at the time of exercise, similar to residents. However, capital gains on the sale of ESOP shares have different tax implications:

• Tax Treaty Benefits: Non-residents can benefit from tax treaties (Double Tax Avoidance Agreements or DTAAs) between India and their resident countries, which may provide relief on capital gains.
• Remittance of Sale Proceeds: For shares sold in India, the gains may be repatriated, but NRI employees need to file tax returns in India to claim refunds or tax credits.

7. Tax Implications of ESOPs for Employers

Employers can claim the ESOP expense as a business expense deduction under the Income Tax Act. The cost incurred by the employer is based on the difference between the market value of shares on the grant date and the exercise price offered to employees, and it can be deducted as an expense over the vesting period of the options.

8. Tax Planning Tips for ESOP Holders

8.1 Exercise ESOPs Strategically

Consider the timing of exercise to avoid high tax liability, as the perquisite tax is based on the FMV on the date of exercise. Exercising during periods of lower valuation may reduce the perquisite tax burden.

8.2 Plan the Sale of Shares for LTCG

Holding shares for more than 12 months after exercise qualifies for long-term capital gains, which attract lower tax rates than short-term gains. Timing the sale strategically can help minimize tax liabilities.

8.3 Use Capital Gains Exemptions and Set-Offs

Long-term capital gains exemptions, such as Section 54EC (investment in specified bonds), may apply to ESOP sales in specific cases. Additionally, capital losses from other investments can be set off against ESOP gains to reduce tax liabilities.

8.4 Utilize Tax Deferral for Startups

If you work for a DPIIT-recognized startup, consider deferring perquisite tax under the tax deferral scheme to optimize cash flow and delay tax payments.

8.5 Track ESOP-Related Documentation

Maintain records of grant letters, vesting schedules, exercise details, FMV on exercise dates, and sale proceeds to accurately calculate taxes and support deductions or exemptions.

9. Reporting ESOPs in Income Tax Return

Report ESOP-related income in the income tax return accurately under the following heads:

1. Salary Income: Perquisite value at the time of exercise.
2. Capital Gains: Gains from the sale of ESOP shares based on holding period and FMV at exercise date.

Documentation for Filing:

• Form 16 from the employer (including TDS on perquisites).
• Brokerage statements for sale transactions.
• Details of the FMV on the exercise date and sale price.

Conclusion

ESOPs can offer substantial financial benefits to employees, but they come with complex tax implications. Understanding the taxation at both the exercise and sale stages is crucial for managing tax liabilities effectively. Strategic planning, such as timing the exercise and sale, utilizing available tax deferrals, and maintaining proper documentation, helps ESOP holders optimize their tax position. Consulting a tax advisor can also provide valuable insights and help navigate the intricacies of ESOP taxation in India.

For more information on GST & other taxation related topics, visit bizconsulting.io.