India’s growing integration with the global economy has made international taxation a significant area of focus for businesses. Two key components of international taxation that companies operating in or dealing with India must understand are Withholding Tax and Transfer Pricing. These are central to cross-border transactions and play a crucial role in compliance, tax planning, and risk mitigation.
This blog delves into the key concepts, legal framework, practical challenges, and compliance requirements related to these two pillars of international taxation in India.
Part 1: Withholding Tax in India
1. What is Withholding Tax?
Withholding tax is an obligation on the part of the payer to deduct tax at source (TDS) when making certain specified payments such as interest, royalty, fees for technical services, and dividends to non-residents or foreign companies.
2. Legal Basis
Withholding tax provisions for payments to non-residents are covered under Section 195 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
- The payer must deduct tax at the time of credit or payment, whichever is earlier.
- Applies even if the non-resident has no presence in India.
- Covers payments such as interest, royalties, technical fees, capital gains, dividends, etc.
3. Key Rates (subject to DTAA relief)
| Nature of Payment | Domestic Rate (%) | DTAA Rate (Typical) |
|---|---|---|
| Interest | 20 | 10 or lower |
| Royalty | 10 | 10 or 15 |
| Fees for Technical Services | 10 | 10 or lower |
| Dividends (to foreign co.) | 20 | 10 or 15 |
| Capital Gains (on shares) | 10/15/20/40 | May vary |
4. DTAA Benefit
Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA) allow non-residents to avail lower withholding tax rates if:
- The non-resident furnishes a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC)
- Form 10F and PAN (in many cases) are submitted
- No PE (Permanent Establishment) exists in India
5. Compliance Requirements
- Deduct TDS under Section 195
- File Form 15CA and Form 15CB (issued by a Chartered Accountant)
- Deposit the tax within 7 days of the end of the month in which the deduction is made
- File quarterly TDS return (Form 27Q)
6. Common Challenges
- Determining the correct rate (DTAA vs domestic)
- Risk of interest and penalties on non-deduction or late payment
- Classification of services (technical vs managerial)
- Determining whether payment is taxable in India under Indian law
Part 2: Transfer Pricing in India
1. What is Transfer Pricing?
Transfer pricing refers to pricing of transactions between associated enterprises (AEs), where one or both entities are non-residents. It ensures that cross-border transactions reflect an arm’s length price (ALP).
2. Legal Framework
India’s transfer pricing regime is governed by Sections 92 to 92F of the Income Tax Act, read with Rule 10A to 10E.
3. Applicability
Applies to:
- International transactions between associated enterprises
- Specified domestic transactions (exceeding a certain threshold)
4. Associated Enterprises (AEs)
Two enterprises are AEs if:
- One participates in the management, control, or capital of the other
- Both are under common control or ownership (threshold of 26% or more equity)
5. Arm’s Length Price (ALP)
ALP is the price which would be charged between unrelated parties in uncontrolled conditions.
6. Methods to Determine ALP
India allows five prescribed methods + one residual method:
- Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP)
- Resale Price Method (RPM)
- Cost Plus Method (CPM)
- Profit Split Method (PSM)
- Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM)
- Any other method as prescribed by CBDT
7. Transfer Pricing Documentation
Mandatory if:
- International transactions exceed INR 1 crore
- Prescribed documentation includes:
- Entity overview
- Transaction details
- Functional, asset, and risk analysis (FAR)
- Economic analysis & benchmarking study
8. Master File & Country-by-Country Reporting (CbCR)
Applicable to international groups with:
- Consolidated turnover > INR 500 crore (Master File)
- Global revenue > EUR 750 million (CbCR)
9. Penalties
| Nature of Default | Penalty |
| Failure to maintain documents | 2% of transaction value |
| Non-reporting of transactions | INR 500,000 |
| Incorrect information furnished | INR 500,000 + prosecution risk |
10. Advance Pricing Agreement (APA)
- An APA is a proactive method of setting ALP in advance for future transactions.
- Can be unilateral, bilateral, or multilateral.
- Reduces litigation, provides certainty.
Part 3: Strategic Insights for Businesses
1. Integrated Planning
Withholding tax and transfer pricing are interlinked. Example:
- Royalty paid to a parent company may involve both transfer pricing and withholding.
2. Audit Preparedness
- Maintain comprehensive documentation
- Conduct mock audits
- Engage with expert advisors
3. Use of Technology
- Deploy ERP systems that track intercompany transactions
- Automate TDS deduction and filing processes
4. Litigation Trends
- Many transfer pricing disputes have reached tribunals and courts
- Withholding tax on software payments, cloud services, and digital advertising are under scrutiny
Conclusion
International taxation, especially Withholding Tax and Transfer Pricing, is a critical compliance area for Indian and foreign companies engaged in cross-border transactions. A thorough understanding of rules, backed by strong documentation, proactive planning, and expert advice, can ensure compliance and mitigate risk.
For Indian businesses expanding globally or MNCs operating in India, managing international tax exposures is not just a matter of legal requirement but a strategic priority.
Let us know
